• About
  • Advertise
Monday, May 23, 2022
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Reality
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    Poetifying the North: Six years of Poetic Wednesdays poetry revival

    Poetifying the North: Six years of Poetic Wednesdays poetry revival

    Monstrous Madrid face Liverpool in UCL final after eliminating Man City

    Monstrous Madrid face Liverpool in UCL final after eliminating Man City

    Transition of Tashe

    Transition of Tashe

    Ronaldo could leave Man United this Summer—Danny Mills

    Ronaldo could leave Man United this Summer—Danny Mills

    ‘RRR’ Review: A visually stunning, exhilarating epic

    ‘RRR’ Review: A visually stunning, exhilarating epic

    Singer, Rema, begs ASUU to call off strike

    Singer, Rema, begs ASUU to call off strike

    World Cup Qualifier: Federal civil servants close from work at 1 pm ahead of Nigeria vs Ghana clash

    World Cup Qualifier: Federal civil servants close from work at 1 pm ahead of Nigeria vs Ghana clash

    Angel Di Maria vacates PSG this season

    Angel Di Maria vacates PSG this season

    Ronaldo, Osaka and Us: Between grit and rethinking

    Ronaldo, Osaka and Us: Between grit and rethinking

  • Local
  • Education
  • International
  • Kannywood
  • Entertainment
  • Religion
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    Poetifying the North: Six years of Poetic Wednesdays poetry revival

    Poetifying the North: Six years of Poetic Wednesdays poetry revival

    Monstrous Madrid face Liverpool in UCL final after eliminating Man City

    Monstrous Madrid face Liverpool in UCL final after eliminating Man City

    Transition of Tashe

    Transition of Tashe

    Ronaldo could leave Man United this Summer—Danny Mills

    Ronaldo could leave Man United this Summer—Danny Mills

    ‘RRR’ Review: A visually stunning, exhilarating epic

    ‘RRR’ Review: A visually stunning, exhilarating epic

    Singer, Rema, begs ASUU to call off strike

    Singer, Rema, begs ASUU to call off strike

    World Cup Qualifier: Federal civil servants close from work at 1 pm ahead of Nigeria vs Ghana clash

    World Cup Qualifier: Federal civil servants close from work at 1 pm ahead of Nigeria vs Ghana clash

    Angel Di Maria vacates PSG this season

    Angel Di Maria vacates PSG this season

    Ronaldo, Osaka and Us: Between grit and rethinking

    Ronaldo, Osaka and Us: Between grit and rethinking

  • Local
  • Education
  • International
  • Kannywood
  • Entertainment
  • Religion
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Reality
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

IGR, VAT controversies: a bright future for northern Nigeria

by Admin
17 September 2021
in Opinion
0
163
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Muhammad Sagir Bauchi

Adam Smith, in “Wealth of Nations”, while discussing what he tagged as “Canon of Taxation”, outlines some principles he describes as “Principles of Good Taxation”. These principles include fairness, certainty, convenience and efficiency. By the principle of fairness, he meant that the taxpayer’s condition should be considered before enforcing tax on him; this is in addition to the ability of the taxpayer to pay the tax. By certainty, the taxpayer should be informed on why he needs to pay his tax and how such taxes are levied on him. By the convenience, he refers to how the taxpayer finds the process of paying the tax as easy as it is. The final principle of efficiency described how the tax payment should have no negative effect on the distribution of resources in the economy.

In a short story, a man came to someone and asked him, “what should I be giving you every day?” He replied: “Sand”. So, as requested, whenever he meets that person, he picks up sand on the ground and hands it over to him. 

One day, that man came to him to collect the sand, but he looked at him abruptly and said, “Why can’t you bend down and fetch it by yourself? Why should I be giving you what you can have if you work hard?”

Recently, there has been an uproar between Federal Inland Revenue Services (FIRS) and Ekiti State Government. As a result, the state government came up with a law regulating Value Added Tax (VAT) collection. With the new law, the Ekiti state government will have absolute power to utilise the VAT generated from that state instead of the usual remittance to the Federation Account! Ab initio, a State high court granted an order to the Ekiti government to move on with their new VAT policy since they have already enacted a law to that effect. Still, a move by the FIRS through the Appeal Court blocked Ekiti State Government from putting the law into effect.

In the beginning, the will to challenge the Federal Government on VAT collection by the states was spearheaded by a single state. Still, by looking at the fruition that may come out from the success of such a legal battle, some states from the South-South joined Ekiti in the suit, thereby sending their representative to the Appellate Court.

Before going further, we need to understand what VAT refers to; for that, we will shed more light on the desperation and motives of these states to have the right to deduct VAT within the economy of their states.

According to FIRS, VAT is “a consumption tax paid when goods are purchased and services rendered“  to this, “all goods produced within or imported into the country are taxable except those specifically exempted by the VAT act”.The authorities responsible for the deduction of the VAT are; indigenous companies with non-resident companies within the country; government ministries, statutory bodies and other agencies of government; and companies operating in the oil and gas sector. These are the statutory bodies saddled with the responsibility of deducting the VAT in Nigeria.

From 2016-2020, Nigeria recorded more than five trillion naira from VAT deduction, but surprising, about three point nine trillion of that amount came from Ekiti and Lagos State. And as usual, the whole amount was shared between the three tiers of government with some amount given to the FIRS for its VAT deduction services! Naturally, human beings are similar to those two people mentioned that one gives sand and the other received, which at the end one expressed tiredness. 

Sentiment aside, it is hard to imagine how a state or region would work diligently harnessing such a hefty amount, in which, in the end, it will be shared with others that contributed little out of it.

Before discovering oil in commercial quantity, the Northern Region of Nigeria was the main contributor to GDP growth, which means that the agricultural sector was the primary source of foreign exchange to the country. But today, despite the contribution of agriculture to the GDP, Northern States rely primarily on what is given from the federation account. Today, it is no longer a secret that only some few Northern states can stand on their own to pay their workers salaries and wages, fulfil their financial commitments, not to mention financing their annual budgets. Most of them would go broke and insolvent if the federal government decided to withhold their monthly allocation for a single month!

To some analysts, the action of Ekiti and Lagos State Governments is nothing but a display of absolute selfishness. Still, to me, it is nothing but expressing their worth and importance to their counterparts.

Amidst this VAT controversy, a new statistical report on Internally Generated Revenue (IGR) of the 36 states of the federation for the fiscal year of 2020 was released. Lagos State is topping the list with about 418bn, Rivers with 117bn and Delta as the third. The report stated that only two Northern States are among the top 10 states with highest IGR, that’s Kaduna and Kano State. And it is not surprising since Kano is the commercial hub of the North. But, surprisingly, even the commercial nerve of the North is generating less IGR than Kaduna. Are commercial activities taking place in Kaduna greater than that of Kano? This shows that there’s transparency and accountability in Kaduna state more than that of Kano.

If one analyses that IGR statistical report and the five-year VAT table, he will weep for the sorry state of the northern states! And the implications of the possible ruling favouring those two states (Ekiti and Lagos) by the Appellate Court against the federal tier, then not only the northern states, but the remaining 34 states would find themselves in deep economic crises.

Then, what should the Northern policymakers do to improve their IGR and move away from dependence on monthly federal allocation?

I foresee a bright future for the northern states out of this development if only their policymakers pursue policies with a serious positive impact on the income of its majority (who are peasant farmers) other than policies that could only favour the wealthy and those in the government. For instance, if the agricultural sector will be given proper attention, thereby coming up with policies that could boost commercial farming through accessibility to quick/soft agro related loans, hybrid seeds with the ability to stand these ever-changing climatic conditions, mechanised farming equipment, setting up subsidised agro-allied chemical industries in the region, provision of good accessible roads connecting all the remote areas, all year round farming and a fair export zones, with these, its unemployed youths will surely seize that opportunity and venture into agro-businesses without looking up to the government for job opportunities in the government sector. But imagine an agricultural intervention program meant to cushion farmers difficulties is deeply flawed in I don’t care attitude of government officials, deliberate delays and nepotism, in the end, such interventions may not meet the majority of farmers on time!

Other regions in Nigeria cannot feed themselves without the support of the Northern farmers. So, why should we be panicking when they try to withhold their money? Why can’t the North stand up and bring out those opportunities? 

Despite the insecurity in almost all parts of the Northern region, one fact that can never be denied is that the area is blessed with arable land, enough for cultivating in dry and rainy seasons. Therefore, adequate farming inputs and machinery should be provided, either in loans or at a subsidised rate by the Northern states governments.

Curbing insecurity is another point that all the governors of the 19 northern states should work hand-in-hand to achieve.

Senators, Representatives and States Assembly members should focus on things that harmonise them with their governors to formulate policies that will boost their states IGR, rather than engage in their usual political war, which deprives millions of citizens of opportunities that may bring development to their livelihood and the region at large.

The impact of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in boasting every economy can never be neglected in every sound economy. But in northern Nigeria, those SMEs are either forced to shut down due to unfriendly tax policies or poor environment to carry out their activities. So, those SMEs should be given more reason to be alive than to seize to exist, thereby granting them soft loans with zero interest or a low interest rate and a friendly environment to carry out their activities.

Most of those states with high IGR have different means of gathering or sourcing revenue within their states. But in the North, both the tax collectors and taxpayers are not up to their responsibility. Therefore, a transparent and professional agency should be enacted in every state with the sole aim of creating awareness on the importance of paying tax, why they should be taxed and the transparent manner in which their tax is utilised.

Lastly, the principle of fairness, certainty, convenience and efficiency should be put into practice to generate more tax to boost IGR for those states.

Sagir writes from Bauchi State and can be reached via ibrahimsagir1227@gmail.com and 07019718681.

Tags: Ekiti StateIGRKaduna StateKano StateLagos StateNorthern NigeriaVAT
Previous Post

Bawa has now recovered—EFCC

Next Post

Man arrested for having sex with goat in Jigawa

Admin

Admin

Related Posts

The liar in the Punch Newspapers

The liar in the Punch Newspapers

by Admin
22 May 2022
2

By Abdullahi O Haruna Haruspice I have never seen a liar like the guy who said his life was under...

Deborah’s Blasphemy and Sokoto Riot: An Open Letter to Bishop Mathew Hassan Kukah

Deborah’s Blasphemy and Sokoto Riot: An Open Letter to Bishop Mathew Hassan Kukah

by Admin
22 May 2022
1

Your one-sided statement lends credence to this assumption. Your position cannot be compared to that of the Sultan, who in the...

2023 elections, Katsina and the curse of anointment

2023 elections, Katsina and the curse of anointment

by Admin
21 May 2022
0

By Salisu Yusuf When President Ibrahim Badamasi Babangida created Katsina State in 1987, we were full of hopes and euphoria...

The unseen tears of firstborns

The unseen tears of firstborns

by Admin
20 May 2022
0

By Fatihu Ibrahim Going through my newsfeed,  I came across a letter dated the 7th of May 2021. Onukwubiri Ifeanyi...

Homeschooling, “American Islam” as seen through a non-American Muslim’s eyes

Homeschooling, “American Islam” as seen through a non-American Muslim’s eyes

by Admin
20 May 2022
1

"Why do you homeschool?" she asked the question I get asked the most." I don't want my kids to be...

Peace beyond religion: Issues around blasphemy and way forward 

Peace beyond religion: Issues around blasphemy and way forward 

by Admin
19 May 2022
0

By Lawan Bukar Maigana  To achieve the relative peace we crave, we must respect each other's religion and be wary...

Load More
Next Post
Man arrested for having sex with goat in Jigawa

Man arrested for having sex with goat in Jigawa

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Katsina: Villagers neutralise armed bandits while collecting ‘tax’

Katsina: Villagers neutralise armed bandits while collecting ‘tax’

1 month ago
Sheikh Daurawa pays tribute to late Dr Ahmad BUK

Sheikh Daurawa pays tribute to late Dr Ahmad BUK

4 months ago

Popular News

    Connect with us

    The Daily Reality

    The Daily Reality

    The Daily Reality is an online news medium with a physical address in Kano State, Nigeria. As our name suggests, we aim to be realistic and truthful to our readers. Moreover, we are an independent, non-partisan company. Thus, we will always do our best to be fair, factual and accurate in our journalism.

    Follow us on social media

    Category

    • Business (14)
    • Education (108)
    • Engausa (5)
    • Entertainment (18)
    • Health (10)
    • International (69)
    • Kannywood (17)
    • Lifestyle (19)
    • Literature (24)
    • Local (130)
    • National (103)
    • News (571)
    • Opinion (566)
    • Politics (89)
    • Religion (78)
    • Science (7)
    • Sports (17)
    • Technology (22)
    • Travel (4)
    • Uncategorized (5)
    Buhari meets, commiserates with families of Kano explosion victims

    Buhari meets, commiserates with families of Kano explosion victims

    23 May 2022
    Boko Haram will be defeated before 2023 – Zulum

    I am not desperate to be Nigeria’s Vice President -Zulum

    23 May 2022
    The liar in the Punch Newspapers

    The liar in the Punch Newspapers

    22 May 2022
    • About
    • Advertise

    © 2021 The Daily Reality - Powered by EasyLife Creative Studio.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
    • Opinion
    • Politics
    • Business
    • National
    • Entertainment
    • International
      • Kannywood

    © 2021 The Daily Reality - Powered by EasyLife Creative Studio.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In