• About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Wednesday, March 29, 2023
  • Login
The Daily Reality
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    PSG, Man Utd, Chelsea scramble to sign Nigerian striker Osimhen

    PSG, Man Utd, Chelsea scramble to sign Nigerian striker Osimhen

    Cristiano Ronaldo puts own private jet up for sale

    Cristiano Ronaldo puts own private jet up for sale

    Luka Modric in talks with Ronaldo’s Alnassr over possible move to Saudi Arabia

    Luka Modric in talks with Ronaldo’s Alnassr over possible move to Saudi Arabia

    Thomas Tuchel set to replace sacked Bayern Munich Manager

    Thomas Tuchel set to replace sacked Bayern Munich Manager

    Why men flirt with waitresses in hotels?

    Why men flirt with waitresses in hotels?

    Can Arsenal be stopped?

    Can Arsenal be stopped?

    Veteran actor ‘Papa Ajasco’ is dead

    Veteran actor ‘Papa Ajasco’ is dead

    Rahama Sadau is just a western copycat

    Rahama Sadau is just a western copycat

    Messi leaving Camp Nou — Barcelona

    We made the best decision by letting Messi go—Barca president

    • Entertainment
  • Local
  • Education
  • International
  • Kannywood
  • Religion
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    PSG, Man Utd, Chelsea scramble to sign Nigerian striker Osimhen

    PSG, Man Utd, Chelsea scramble to sign Nigerian striker Osimhen

    Cristiano Ronaldo puts own private jet up for sale

    Cristiano Ronaldo puts own private jet up for sale

    Luka Modric in talks with Ronaldo’s Alnassr over possible move to Saudi Arabia

    Luka Modric in talks with Ronaldo’s Alnassr over possible move to Saudi Arabia

    Thomas Tuchel set to replace sacked Bayern Munich Manager

    Thomas Tuchel set to replace sacked Bayern Munich Manager

    Why men flirt with waitresses in hotels?

    Why men flirt with waitresses in hotels?

    Can Arsenal be stopped?

    Can Arsenal be stopped?

    Veteran actor ‘Papa Ajasco’ is dead

    Veteran actor ‘Papa Ajasco’ is dead

    Rahama Sadau is just a western copycat

    Rahama Sadau is just a western copycat

    Messi leaving Camp Nou — Barcelona

    We made the best decision by letting Messi go—Barca president

    • Entertainment
  • Local
  • Education
  • International
  • Kannywood
  • Religion
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Reality
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

The Abduljabbar Saga: Where he got it wrong – Prof. Yakubu Azare

Admin by Admin
12 July 2021
in Opinion
17
The Abduljabbar Saga: Where he got it wrong – Prof. Yakubu Azare
0
SHARES
5.1k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I followed the entire debacle that lasted slightly above five hours with the attendant result from the moderator, Professor Salisu Shehu. It was thorough and the laid down procedural regulations were apt and full. I don’t intend to review what happened there; I intend to explain a phenomenon I viewed to have made Abduljabbar slipped. The entire dispute revolves around the concept of translation, which is seen as a primary machine that allows us to decipher messages encoded in another language. The whole concept of understanding religious principles is encapsulated in its translation into the language we fully understand. For any text to be wholly deciphered, there has to be suitable communicative translation and faithful in some instances—failure of translation results in catastrophe. As we often tell our students, a slight mistake in translation could trigger unrest. The case of Abduljabbar is one pointer.

Sacred texts should be translated with uttermost caution to avoid pitfalls and possible uproar. Therefore, aspects of semantic addition and omission are not so much at the liberty of the translator. Of course, the translation author can be – and is – allowed to make additions or omissions, where necessary, to press meaning to the audience; however, in the case of sacred texts (mostly religious documents), such liberties are highly restricted. 

Overall, the whole saga was about Abduljabbar making unsubstantiated claims about certain prophetic traditions, which he claimed were mistakes by some of the finest scholars that history can never forget. He attributed certain heavy libellous statements to these scholars. Abduljabbar often reads the Arabic rendition with subsequent translation and exegesis of the tradition. This is a usual trend by all Ulamas intending to communicate across people of diverse linguistic backgrounds. What is worthy of noting here is how the original message is rendered and transmitted into the receptor language, in this case, Hausa.

See also  Celebrating General Ibrahim Attahiru in death

Almost throughout the debate, there was a conspicuous absence of direct utterances of Abduljabbar in the original Hadith. This narrows down the accusing finger to Abduljabbar. No amount of denial or persistent argument would absolve him from the shackles of law and accusations. The exegesis cum translations here are, therefore, the root cause. Cultural nuances are essential to issues worthy of consideration when translating, as diverse cultures have varying ways of apportioning meaning to certain utterances. Abduljabbar was, quite evidently, never considerate of such slippery edges. Instead, he translated, explained and attributed conclusions to statements entirely out of context in the bid to attain heroism, demonstrate a more profound or better understanding of the scriptures.

Adding so much into translation in most instances has the tendency of making meaning obscure and or vague. Sacred texts are not only carefully knitted but are sometimes seen as dogmatic. In other words, religious texts express what they appear to have said. Making unnecessary addition may result in meaning change. Abduljabbar was attacked based on his utterances throughout, and in all the challenges posed to him, the central question is, where did you see this or that. Wrong translation understandably played a key role. In one such case, the moderator drew his attention to the contextual meaning and differences between “Haajaa and Shahawaa“. He explained that the former could not be given the contextual meaning of the latter. Each has its way of being expressed to denote what is intended.

See also  On the need for mass transit in Kano

Thus, between Hausa and Arabic, some cultural differences arise in how they attach meanings to ideas, subjects and so on; nonetheless, Abduljabbar was not so keen on that. Instead, he occupies the Arabic messages with haphazard translations that devour our cultural and religious context and, often, sensibilities. Both in our religion and culture, the place of the Prophet (SAW) is sacred, secured and untouchable. Therefore, making and creating controversial statements to his person is not only wrong but blasphemous. All the traditions cited by Abduljabbar and the other clerics, there was no one place, and I mean one place, that equates the heavy words of Abduljabbar in his Hausa explanation.

The central point here is, wrong and mismanaged translation played a significant role in this saga. It suffices to say, “Translation is a serious business and is not haphazardly done.” Understand, and master its art before engaging in it. Be vast in the cultural nuances of both languages, and understand that pragmatics is key to assigning meaning to words in certain situations. Also, know that sacred texts do not go with our whimsical preferences. Additions or omissions are made with caution to avoid slippery edges.

May Allah guide us always. May peace and blessings be on our most revered Prophet.

Prof. Yakubu Magaji Azare wrote from Bayero University, Kano. He can be reached via ymazare@yahoo.com.

Tags: Coalition of Kano UlamaKano State GovernmentProphet Muhammad (SAW)Sheikh Abduljabbar KabaraTranslation
Previous Post

JUST IN: Shehu Sani resigns from PRP

Next Post

On the Abduljabbar debate – Binta Spikin

Next Post
On the Abduljabbar debate – Binta Spikin

On the Abduljabbar debate - Binta Spikin

Comments 17

  1. Abba Balancology says:
    2 years ago

    Masha Allah

    Reply
  2. Maryam hussain usman says:
    2 years ago

    Ameen ya hayyu ya kayyum.we are really proud of u our able prof.Allah ya kara basira.

    Reply
  3. Haruna Muhammad Tukur says:
    2 years ago

    Ma sha Allah.
    Our Prof. Jazaakallaahu khairan.
    Your Student at BUK, DAHIS Class of 2000-2002.
    We really benefited a lot from your Course thrn, if I can recall well “Techniques of Translation”. May Allah, the Almighty increase you more in sound knowledge and good understanding.
    H. M. Tukur 0803 416 5633.

    Reply
  4. Jamilu Abdullahi says:
    2 years ago

    Allah ya saka da alheri Prof.

    Reply
  5. Musa Tadda says:
    2 years ago

    Allaahumma Ameen.
    Well said.
    Thank you and more ink to your pen, Prof. Azare.
    Jazaakallahu khairah.

    Reply
  6. Y G Abdalah says:
    2 years ago

    Ikhlas of intention is the most important issue in passing knowledge to others.

    Reply
  7. habibu usman sayyidi says:
    2 years ago

    Alhamdulillah. May Almighty Allah protect you in all your life activities.
    No doubt, you are the kind of professor that the entire Muslims ummah will be proud of. Jakumullahu khair.

    Reply
  8. Aisha Auwalu Saleh says:
    2 years ago

    May Allah preserve our iman and protect us from exceeding His limits. Amin

    Reply
  9. ANNUR AHMAD MUHAMMAD says:
    2 years ago

    GOOD OBSERVATION OUR PROFESSOR!

    Reply
  10. Munzali gaya says:
    2 years ago

    Alhmdllh

    Reply
  11. Zaharaddeen Kallah says:
    2 years ago

    Of course, translation matters in this context. But looking at the connections of Abduljabbar outside the country and allegation that has to do with a particular sect, may be unconnected with the translation issue. This maybe a deliberate attempt to serve as a litmus test.

    Reply
  12. Hassan Yusuf says:
    2 years ago

    Well said indeed. You really wrote magnificently

    Reply
  13. muhammad muhamma musa says:
    2 years ago

    Ameen ya hayyu ya qayyum
    Allah saka da alkairi

    Reply
  14. Abdullahi Magaji says:
    2 years ago

    A balanced analysis. May Allah increase you in knowledge. Proud of you to be a product of Guddiri.

    Reply
  15. Awal says:
    2 years ago

    My dear prof, please call a spade by its name…

    Reply
  16. Umar says:
    2 years ago

    Well articulated Prof! You have said it all. More ink to your mighty pen sir.

    Reply
  17. Abdurrashid Muhammad says:
    2 years ago

    Ameen

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

PWI at 6: A Northern Nigerian Literary Voyage

PWI at 6: A Northern Nigerian Literary Voyage

11 months ago
Three people killed as gunmen attack Benue community

Three people killed as gunmen attack Benue community

5 months ago

Popular News

  • An open letter to Barrister Abba Hikima

    Re: An open letter to Barrister Abba Hikima

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • “All this hardship I am going through is for you to be educated”: My Mother’s words that always sound in my ears

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Connect with us

Facebook Twitter
The Daily Reality

The Daily Reality

The Daily Reality is an online news medium with a physical address in Kano State, Nigeria. As our name suggests, we aim to be realistic and truthful to our readers. Moreover, we are an independent, non-partisan company. Thus, we will always do our best to be fair, factual and accurate in our journalism.

Follow us on social media

Category

  • Business (79)
  • Education (300)
  • Engausa (10)
  • Entertainment (34)
  • Health (65)
  • International (181)
  • Kannywood (39)
  • Lifestyle (52)
  • Literature (37)
  • Local (313)
  • National (383)
  • News (1,323)
  • Opinion (1,026)
  • Politics (388)
  • Religion (177)
  • Science (15)
  • Security (43)
  • Sports (40)
  • Technology (62)
  • Travel (6)
  • Uncategorized (2)
Barau Jibril, Nigeria’s 10th senate leadership and BAT

Barau Jibril, Nigeria’s 10th senate leadership and BAT

29 March 2023
Language and the specific gravity of identity

Hausa names as ethnographic identifiers

29 March 2023
Ramadan: ABU Professor distributes 40 bags of rice to students

Ramadan: ABU Professor distributes 40 bags of rice to students

29 March 2023

© 2022 The Daily Reality - Powered by EasyLife Creative Studio.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Business
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • International
    • Kannywood

© 2022 The Daily Reality - Powered by EasyLife Creative Studio.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In